[Very nice post above kartoffel. Hope you get some thanks for that one

]
Lylo wrote:I guess I am just saying is "Don't we need a target?"!

Yep, you are absolutely right Lylo.
If I was designing a recipe from scratch, I would definitely use the BJCP guidelines. I am thinking they would be based on scientific measurements rather than the formulas we are forced to use.
The main problem occurrs (like with any recipe conversion) when you try to convert the BJCP IBU's (or any IBU's, for that matter) into a recipe. I buggered up the link in my last post
here. Have edited it now. There you will see that the exact same recipe can give three totally different IBU predictions depending on the formula used.
So...
Make sure that whatever program/calculator you use to estimate those IBU's given by the BJCP uses the TInseth formula.
Finally, check that the program or calculator you use, matches the IBU's given in The Calculator (or THe BIABacus when it is released) as there are a lot of errors in Tinseth calculations in existing software.
PP
P.S. I'm having eyesight problems atm which makes it very difficult to read and write. Apologies to Yeasty and others that I won't be able to help out here for a while. (Yeasty, by the look of his last post, I reckon kartoffel will definitely be able to help out

)
If you have found
the above or anything else of value on BIABrewer.info, consider supporting us by
getting some BIPs!