Tinseth vs. IBU

First post by Primavera, 3 years ago

First post

---

Can someone point me to a good source to understand the difference between the two bitterness measurements?

Last post

---

Hey Primavera, I just reread this post for...probably the third or fourth time in the past couple or three weeks.

I've been doing studying and research on hops and hopping...hoping to ascertain a greater level of understanding. If interested, believe my posts are in the hops or hopping sections on this website.

From one of your posts on this you mentioned Stone's IPA. Most likely Stone Brewing is not just relying on IBU formula estimate (i.e. Tinseth ). They certainly use a formula estimate,...

Hydrometer readings in clear or cloudy.

First post by Muggy Dawson, 1 year ago

First post

---

I've recently purchased a second hydrometer and was thinking today as a tested my latest batches, does it make a difference if the sample is of clear wort or if there is some trub/cloudiness in it?
I imagine I could test this with a 'very cloudy' Vs 'reasonably clear' set of samples, but my samples would be hard to fix values to.

Last post

---

Hey Muggy,

Short answer is I think you're okay. If you have trub at the bottom you would want to have enough / excess wort in the container so the hydrometer isn't sitting at the top of the trub layer, as that would mess up your numbers.

If anyone else has different or additional info please feel free to chime in.

Brewing calculators and software

First post by vexedben, 1 year ago

First post

---

I'm not sure if this is the right place to post this put here goes.

I've been looking at all the various brewing calculators like brewers friend and beer smith and have come across biabacus on this forum as well. Can anyone offer me any advice as to which is the best calculator to use for a novice and any tips as to where to begin with it.

Thanks in advance.

Last post

---

Thanks for all your feedback on this. It certainly cleared it up in my mind which one to use.

I will give Biabacus a go for my next brew and see how I get on. There does seem to be plenty of support on this forum which I will no doubt turn to when I get stuck filling it in. :)

Water Volumes help

First post by dogpond, 1 year ago

First post

---

Hi I am new to BIAB and have done about 4 brews so far. I have been making great beer though the one thing I cant seem to sort is the volumes. 2 of my brews now have been 3 litres short and the other two have been perfect based on the volumes of the spreadsheet. My answer for now is just to always put 2 litres extra in so I am either 2 over or 1 short. This does affect my OG though. I put the details in to Brewsmith to for one of the brews that was 3 litres out and their TWN was also about 4...

Last post

---

Thanks mate that is so much simpler than i was makimg it out to be. I will start using those other sections on spreadsheet now!

Measuring volume by weight

First post by Mad_Scientist, 1 year ago

First post

---

I measured a little more than 80 kg (weight) into my kettle. I heated up tap water to 40 c, removed water till it was at 80 kg. I made a small mark on my sight glass.

I have an answer, but want to confirm.

I found a factor of 0.99225 to use when tap water is at 40 c.

How much volume do I have at the same height when it is at ambient / cooled?

Sent from my XT1053 using Tapatalk

Last post

---

MS - With that gorgeous electronic balance (scale) that can handle 80 kilograms as shown in your photo, why worry about the sight glass? Use the density numbers mentioned in posts above with your balance to get the amount of starting water you seek at the temperature you have. Keep track of the weights (grains + hops + any other stuff) you add to the kettle - assuming that you add them in pre-weighed portions if 28 gms of hops wouldn't show up on your electronic display of Kg. Then, by weight,...

BIABacus — where to keep notes during a brew?

First post by rsandilands, 3 years ago

First post

---

Hi there

I'm using the BIABacus and am wondering where other brewers keep notes during the course of a brew?

For instance, I like to keep notes about temp changes, gravity readings, obversations etc

I'm aware of the 'Special Instructions/Notes' field but on my mac, this doesn't allow paragraph breaks so it gets a little unwieldy in there.

Last post

---

Take a look at this thread. I use the sheets from it and add other notes in the margins if needed.

Calculating IBU's

First post by flhb, 2 years ago

First post

---

I was reading the May 2nd post on brulosophy.com comparing a hop stand to a traditional 20 min hop addition when and I came across a paragraph that I thought this site would appreciate:

... These results also leave me curious about IBU formulas. The boiled hops batch was projected to be at 115 IBU compared to just 84 IBU for the hop stand beer. However, lab testing proved that not only were the beers nearly similar, but that the hop stand beer was actually slightly more bitter (by 2 IBU) than...

Last post

---

Well, my intent wasn't to have a long discussion on brulosophy and experimenting in general, but it's interesting anyways.

Multiple Biabacus files to create your shopping list?

First post by Inconceivable, 2 years ago

First post

---

Hi to all

I have a question about querying/ looking up data across a lot of Biabacus files and wonder if someone has already solved this challenge and can tell me how.

I have been loading my to-brew recipes into individual Biabacus files and setting them aside for future use. It'd be nice to be able to query all of these files to determine what ingredients I'll need to brew them all. For example if I have six recipes loaded into six different Biabacus files and I want to know how much Cascade...

Last post

---

...I might refer the question to my finance types at work under the guise of real work haha.
I'd imagine since it's a known cell location in each workbook it'll be possible; but perhaps not with freeware
Will update if I crack the case Good stuff ;).

The key will be not using any macros so it would be fantastic if they can come up with a solution.

I'm tempted, in some ways, to put the final release of the BIABacus out as a LibreOffice file :scratch:. The advantage of doing that would be it...

Measuring volumes for a eKeggle

First post by nosco, 2 years ago

First post

---

Hi all. Sorry for lack of research but my searchings didn't really find anything specific enough.

I am building a keggle for a mate who wants to get into brewing with the idea of doing it as cheap as I can. Its looking pretty good and since I heard of a trub ring which wont work with my element I am thinking of building one for myself. Everything is nearly up and running but then I realised I don't know how to measure volumes in a keg. It may be just gas for starters but Im thinking of going...

Last post

---

Thanks Mad Scientist. Yep Ive already drilled the holes in the skirt. I will just have to calibrate it the old fashioned way with a measuring jug and take the false bottom into account or ill try seam to seam as well. I did notice though that the poly tube sight glasses (I think thats what you are using) are alot cheaper than the heavy duty ones. I dont think they where around last time I was looking. I might have to rethink it as an option. Ill be using your bag design too ;)

Cheers.

Relative Bitterness Ratio

First post by Brew4me, 2 years ago

First post

---

I an attempt to learn - thought I would see if others had any thoughts on the Mad alchemist article on relative bitterness ratio. Any thoughts of this type of measurement in future release of BIABacus?

Pete

Last post

---

Thanks PP :salute: - good to know - lesson learned

How much water?

First post by beer4, 2 years ago

First post

---

Hi Guys,

I would like to brew a 23 Lt brew,I will be using 5 kg's of malt, this will be my first ever BIAB, I want to keep it simple, so this will be a smash beer, Malt and cascade hops, I am not sure how much water I should start with? to end up with 23lt, any idea's ?

Last post

---

Hi Joshua & Pistol Patch,

Thanks for your assistance I haven't yet bought the grains, for the last eight years I have had good results as an extract & speciality grains brewer, I want to take the next step and brew all grain. I will have a good look at the BIABacus, once again thanks

BIABacus Estimate Efficiency

First post by Shumanfoo, 2 years ago

First post

---

How accurate are the estimated efficiency numbers?

I've brewed 4 beers so far and I've been fairly close to the estimated numbers in each of the brews so far. I've made beers from about 1.040 to 1.060 in OG. Right now I'm working on a Tripel recipe which is much bigger OG (going for 1.085 or so) and grain bill than I have done before. From what I understand, BIABacus adjusts estimated efficiency depending on some factors. In this case, efficiency went down and I'm assuming due to grain amount...

Last post

---

Rickoles - I would if it were cane sugar that hadn't been opened (They tend to be hygroscopic)!
Corn sugar, or other forms that have some moisture would have to be either adjusted/calculated/guessed at accordingly too as they will all have their own extract potential.

Thinking aloud - I would guess the best way to quantify would be to make a solution and measure the gravity....

Or just throw it in and see :lol:

I want 23 liter batch size but my kettle is only 25 liter

First post by Kangarooster, 3 years ago

First post

---

Hello!

I will soon make my second batch of beer. My first batch only ended up with 7 liters, but I want to make more this time. But as the title says I am currently limited by my small kettle.

What I am wondering is if there are any drawbacks to using a full scale (23 l) recipe with regard to grain amount, but utilize less water for mashing (i.e. make a more concentrated mash), and then gradually add boiling water to the pot during the boil step in an effort to arrive at a final batch size...

Last post

---

Thanks again. For my next brew I will try this. :)

BIABacus - a few questions

First post by chesl73, 3 years ago

First post

---

Hi

Not sure if this is the right area for it but I've been looking at the BIABacus in preparation for my first BIAB and I had a few questions.

I've just got a new kettle, a 19L kettle and I was planning on doing a mini-BIAB using the recipe American Pale Ale - NRB's All Amarillo APA.

To check a few things with the kettle I put in 12.10L of water as per the BIABacus TWN reading and I measured with a ruler and heated it up to strike temp and then onto a full boil which I left going for 30 mins...

Last post

---

Partially off should be fine. The steam will escape just fine as long as you are maintaining a good boil.

How do I measure the water

First post by Philip321, 3 years ago

First post

---

My pot measures: Height = 38.5cm and Diameter = 39.5
Please could someone let me know the link or tell me how do I measure the water in the pot?

Last post

---

My pot measures: Height = 38.5cm and Diameter = 39.5
Please could someone let me know the link or tell me how do I measure the water in the pot?

Hi Philip,

Considering your pot's datas, it's a 47L

You can measur the water in the pot with a meter... 1 cm of water (in your pot) equal 1.23 liters.

Cheers,

How much water

First post by Philip321, 3 years ago

First post

---

I intend to do a Bag End Bitter from this recipe:-

The recipe States Water Required 8.44 gal (which is probably US Gallons) and Volume into Fermenter = 5.25 gal = 19.87 Litres

but when I enter the recipe on the BIABacus it states Total Water Needed (TWN) 29.83 Litres = 7.88 Gals and (Hot) Strike Water Needed (SWN) 30.42 Litres = 8.04 Gals

My Question is Do I put 8.44 Gals or 7.88 Gals into the boiler?
Do I follow the recipe or the BIABacus?

Last post

---

Thank you both for your replies.

So TWN is what I put into the boiler.
I've read the terminology and it sais SWN is 2% more than TWN because water swells when it is heated.

I made a mistake on the brew I have just completed (My first brew). I put SWN amount into the boiler which is 0.59 Litres to much.

My Pre Boil gravity reading @ 58 degrees Celcius was 1.014 and when it cooled to 19.7 degrees celcius it was 1.032

Do you think these gravity readings are OK?

Don't take any gravity...

BIABacus — how to adjust grain absorption?

First post by rsandilands, 3 years ago

First post

---

Just brewed a batch today and my Volume into Boil (VIB) was higher than anticipated by my BIABacus spreadsheet.

So the spreadsheet is overestimating my grain absorption rate — where can I amend the default for this?

I was expecting to do so in Section X but can't see the appropriate amount there.

Last post

---

Thanks MS for taking the time with this, it was useful to see your xls.

I squeeze pretty hard, bag on a rack on top of the kettle and use the kettle lid, then into a colander where I squeeze some more so I'm closer to 0.5l/kg it seems than the defaults.

I brewed my Brown Ale yesterday, first batch using the BIABacus, and hit my pre-boil and gravity of ambient wort (GAW) numbers on the dot: 1.046 and 1.056 respectively, exactly as estimated by the BIABacus, so that was satisfying. Only opened...

Biabacus Dry and Liqid malt extract potential adjustments

First post by nik, 3 years ago

First post

---

Hi after a long time ,I would like to know if anyone has Extract potentials of Liquid , Dry malt extracts ,honey and whatever else (Candy sugar etc ect) in order to have this data handy when I use them to fill the Y section on the Biabacus...
Thank you in advance!!!!!!

Last post

---

Thanks for answering Pat this year so far is quite difficult for me regarding free time but I still brewing this time I moved to smaller batches inside (8 liters) with a small pot (17 liter) and feel happy again biabacus is a tool of choice. We talk with Kostas because he is a member of Greek homebrewers association as me and we spend time organizing things.

Στάλθηκε από το C1905 μου χρησιμοποιώντας Tapatalk

Heast loss/transfer with BIAB

First post by bionut, 3 years ago

First post

---

I brewed only using BIAB, besides some canned kits at the beginins. Every body that does BIAB say that this method, using the entire volume of water for mashing is better for keeping a good constant temperature during the mash. OK, seems logic, but the theory says that this way you will rather loss more heat than using a smaller volume of water.
I am refering to this formula Q=U*A*ΔT, saying that the heat loss of an area of size A is determined by the U heat transfer coeficient and the...

Last post

---

Google square-cube law , pretty straightforward scientific explanation for this.

A New Approach to BIAB Calculus using Conversion Efficiency

• 1
• 2
• 3
• 4

First post by stux, 7 years ago

First post

---

This is a BIAB calculator which uses a Novel method to calculate your grainbill, which is independant of Into Boil Efficiency , and works well with large beers, with or without sparging

It's very accurate.
...

I've been working on a solution to a problem which affects all BIABers who are using BIAB calculators to determine their volumes and grain bills :)

I think I've cracked it ;)

The problem is this, as you increase the gravity of the wort you are creating the effciency goes down. Most...

Last post

---

I still use my calculator, unmodified to calculate the water and grainbill requirements for all my batches.

The thing that came up is that the grain specifications became the critical factor in achieving more reliable predictions, and I found as grain got older the measured conversion efficiency went down. My theory is that the grain was actually getting more moist over time.

At the end of the day, I don't really see much point in attempting to further refine the maths, when its impractical...

Measurements for Craftbrewer 70L kettle?

First post by nicko, 3 years ago

First post

---

Hi guys,

Does anyone with a Craftbrewer 70 litre kettle (45cm x 45cm) have their water level measurements written down somewhere? I.e. As an example, If the kettle has 44L in it, what's the distance from the rim to the water surface?

Just trying to save myself some time on brew days. I wrote down the measurement on the last brew but must have misplaced it unfortunately! If anyone is keen to help start a register that would be great! I have a carbon filter for my hose from a caravan/RV, so...

Last post

---

Thanks gents!

Using BIABacus in Chrome Web browser.

First post by bundy, 3 years ago

First post

---

Guys, I just tried using BIABacus with Google's new Add-in for Chrome Office Editing for Docs

and lo and behold BIABacas seems to work perfectly.

My testing wasn't thorough but I tried changing a few things such as;

Desired VIF
Hop AA%
Desired Gravity
Changed Evap Rate
Desired IBU's

Each time the BIABacus Spreadsheet Recalculated and did what it was supposed to. :thumbs:

This may be a very handy add-in for those living in the Apple or I-Pad worlds (Yet to test it on those platforms,...

Last post

---

There's always something bundy :roll:.

LibreOffice works well on any platform and stays protected as long as users always save the file as an .xls. The only change that occurs is in the colours but that is not much to worry about.

(See you Saturday :drink:)