Thanks PP!
The beer definitely came out tasting as I planned - easy drink (I would have added a bit more hops - but I wasn't the requester jsut the brewer on this one

).
I think I know what you are getting at and I agree on the comment about "really tasting" the beer. I usually take the first one or two on my own to critique. Its pretty cool working with the all grain - I definitely can taste the different malts and hops when I drink beer now then I ever noticed before. I started tasting the malt prior to brewing to see if I can identify flavors and freshness -

training the palette I guess.
With regards to the color, I thought the color was a bit darker but gave it little thought (kind of parallel to your first comment - am I taking the time to really review my work and answering any open questions = best I open a beer and get critiquing

) - but your comment on the crystal is likely the reason.
Brew4me