Post #15 made 7 years ago
by DanIAm
[font=Open Sans]"[/font][font=Open Sans]I thought I'd try a couple of SMASHes just to get a feel for how the ingredients change things"[/font]
The good ole scientific method is the best way of doing it isn't it, got to try it and get a feel rather than blindly follow recipes where you get a result but little knowledge of why you ended up where you did.
It's hard in brewing in that the process is so long, by the time it's in your glass, unless you've got an eidetic memory it's hard to remember what things smelled/tasted like on brew day.
But Hops is easy, make a cup of tea with them.
Not for bittering, that is something you just calculate how much for how long with a known alpha acid (though the balance between it and malt is where the artisanl aspect lays). But Flavour/aroma, with short amounts in the boil, the oils come out and gives us access to the aroma and flavor of the hops. The simple test if you want to know your ingredients is to line up a tiny amount of hops in a cup and put boiling water in it, do it with a number of hops and you can get a comparison about 5 minutes for aroma and 10 for flavour (some flavour hops are added at 20 mins, but the aromas will have mostly gone and taste needs aroma to properly work - you lose your sense of taste if you have a blocked nose for example). Water is fine, you'll get acquainted with the hop itself, but for context, you could dissolve in some dme or lme or if really elaborate a tiny hint of alcohol (vodka or something as tasteless as possible). It means you can line up a few different hops next to each other for comparison and only spend a few minutes, whereas within a brew it takes hours and it's impractical to compare numbers of different hops.
Grain. You'll typically use 1 base malt - Marris Otter is perfect for most ales (English, APA's etc), Pilsener for Pilseners etc. But what other grains and how much is the harder thing. But how to know how all the grains taste/smell? More elaborate, but you can do an equivalent to the hop tea.
Mashing is in the ballpark of 5kg of grain to 30+(ish) liters which ends up as 20 liters of wort. So, if you were able to get some form of water bath from a small benchtop home kitchen to chefs kitchen size or otherwise get good temperature control... Put a number of 1 litre containers of water in the bath, when the temperature is at strike point (eg 66C), put in 100 grams of range of grains in the different containers and stir periodically and basically follow your mash schedule, no need to boil, you'll get the idea after mash. vienna vs munich vs pilsener vs marris otter vs rye vs wheat comparisons would be interesting, or a range of speciality malts. Some malts are more biscuit like, others - e.g specialty malts give caramel and other things (almond, dried fruit etc).
But see if you can do the experiment at the lhbs or via a local homebrew group. Share the experiment and knowledge, I'd be bamboozled for a week if you didn't find several people at the lhbs or homebrew group also interested.