However apart from such hyperbole the book is a great read, and a couple of snippets interested me about current (2007) practices:
They run the beer at 25°C for 60 hours, then mature for a full 3 days
I was surprised to find that the major dark grain is roasted malt in the mash to give a brown colour to the wort, not roasted barley. There is RB, but this is added after mashing in the form of an extract.
There is also a further secret "extract" added later. Whaddya bet it's a small portion of Brett fermented stout?
I wasn't going to do a stout this year but after reading the book I was tonguing for a creamy rich stout, so did one today. I added the Roast Barley to the mashout, and used some acidulated malt in the mash to see if I can get a bit of that hint of lactic.
edit: and I've got a good healthy starter of Wyeast Irish Ale 1084 which I am going to run at 24° - have done so in the past and it works great, I wouldn't mind betting it's related to the Guinness yeast.